Thursday, March 12, 2009

STEGER: FUNDRAISER NOT LEADER

There appears to be a breakdown in the way at least one of Virginia’s institutions of higher learning picks its presidents—I am talking about Virginia Tech. If you read the biography of Virginia Tech’s President, Charles Steger, you are struck by the heavy emphasis on his ability to raise money—and the lack of emphasis on leadership. This breakdown in selection criteria had horrific consequences on April 16, 2007.

Many have commented that the terrible shootings at Virginia Tech are symptomatic of broader problems in our colleges and universities, in our society in general, and in our values. They are correct. These shortcomings cannot be glossed over. A good place to start correcting the problem is to change the hiring profile for university presidents. Schools, and specifically Virginia Tech, should base the selection of their presidents on leadership not fundraising abilities.

If you read the official biography of Dr. Charles Steger that was published when he was named Virginia Tech’s 15th president, you are struck by the emphasis on his ability to raise money. The total number of words in the biography is 969, of that, 184 tout his fundraising abilities—that is nearly one-quarter of the biography. This fundraising ability may—inadvertently—have turned into a liability on April 16, 2007. Look at the words in Steger’s official biography:

“In Dr. Steger’s previous position as Vice President for Development and University Relations, he directed the university’s successful (fund raising) campaign, which raised $337.4 million, exceeding the $250 million goal by 35 percent. It was the most successful fundraising effort in the university’s history. Over 71,000 donors and 500 volunteers participated in this six-year nationwide effort led by Dr. Steger.”

“In addition, he (Steger) currently serves as president of the Endowment Foundation for the Western Virginia Foundation for the Arts and Sciences (known as Center in the Square) in Roanoke. Dr. Steger also is director on the Boswil Foundation in Zyrich (sic) Switzerland. He received Outstanding Fund Raising Executive Award given by the First Virginia Chapter of the National Society of Fund Raising Executives in 1999 at its national Philanthropy Day Awards Dinner.”

Virginia Tech, on the eve of the shooting, was preparing for the school’s largest on-campus fundraiser in history. The nagging question is did Steger “want” the first shootings at West Ambler Johnston residence hall to be outcome of some sort of lovers quarrel because the publicity would be easier to handle than a campus shooting rampage. Did Steger hope against hope that the first two murders were the product of a love triangle; the publicity would have been relatively easy to handle and not distract from the upcoming fundraiser? Or did Steger want the shootings to be a failed robbery attempt or a drug deal gone bad? In both cases the publicity would have been easier to deal with. One cannot help but wonder—did Steger intentionally delay issuing a campus-wide warning?

Now we find out that Virginia Tech President Steger has been awarded the “Chief Executive Leadership Award” at the Council for the Advancement and Support of Education (CASE) District III at their annual conference in Atlanta, Georgia on February 8-11, 2009. In presenting the award, CASE III board member Matt Winston, assistant to the president of the University of Georgia, noted Steger’s “Clark Kent” qualities of quiet leadership and determination. Yes, as a matter of fact Steger’s leadership was so quiet on April 16, 2007, that it didn’t show up. Indeed, Steger’s lack of leadership on that fateful day is a monument to indecision and vacillation.

I find the reference to Clark Kent baffling. Clark Kent is a comic book figure who become a superhero when faced with danger. President Steger became a fumbling, bumbling, bureaucrat on the morning of April 16, 2007. He didn’t save any lives—he cost the lives of 30 people at Norris Hall.

In the nine months before April 16, 2007, Virginia Tech cancelled classes three times because of threats of campus violence, and professors had received close to a dozen email warnings of gunmen on campus, multiple bomb threats to academic buildings, and violent physical attacks on campus. On the morning of April 16, 2007 two students lay dead on a dormitory floor and bloody foot prints led away from the crime. Steger hesitated; Steger did not spring into action when confronted with danger; Steger was not a super hero—he was weak.

If Virginia Tech President Charles Steger is Clark Kent—please someone get the kryptonite.

Sunday, March 1, 2009

STEGER’S WORDS: SELF-INDICTMENT

Following the brutal murder of graduate student, Xin Yang on January 21, 2009, on the Virginia Tech campus, school President Charles Steger issued a statement designed to reassure the school and public alike that Virginia Tech was doing all it could to ensure the safety of everyone on the campus. His words however, were more unnerving than reassuring.

Virginia Tech should be in the forefront of campus security, but it is not. President Steger’s words clearly demonstrate how far behind Virginia Tech security is when compared to other schools, such as the State University, Oneonta, New York. His words were meant to reassure by highlighting what the school has done since the terrible events on April 16, 2007. In fact, his words underscore how little Virginia Tech as done. President Steger’s words are, in many respects, a self-indictment of his continued poor leadership. Take a look at what he had to say:

1. “At Virginia Tech we have added 11 positions to the VTPD and now have 70- person police and security force.” In an earlier blog I went into the security measures that the State University New York-Oneonta (SUNY-Oneonta) has enacted. It is worth comparing those measures with Steger’s words. SUNY Oneonta, New York has put in place:

a. The ability to lock down every building on campus (with the exception of the gym) with four strokes on the computer keyboard.
b. Radio systems in all buildings for emergency use.
c. Blue prints of all campus buildings on hand in the police headquarters in case of an emergency.
d. A campus-wide siren for notification that there is an emergency on campus.
e. SUNY-Oneonta will soon have in place a video and card access system for all campus buildings.
f. SUNY-Oneonta has bought and installed a sophisticated key system for all buildings. The keys cannot be duplicated.

2. According to Steger, “University officials continue to work very closely with each other to identify and evaluate students in need. The Treat Assessment Team and the Care Team meet regularly to assist students with problems in school or personal life. The Threat Assessment Team also intervenes when it appears that an individual could be a threat to self or others in our community (students, employees, or visitors).” Compare Steger’s words with the program at SUNY Oneonta:

a. A Behavioral Assessment Team that meets every week to discuss student problems and activities. The group is made up of Police Chief Ingersoll, the Director of Counseling, the Director of Residence Life, the Associate Vice President for Judicial Affairs, the Vice President of Student Development, and the Health Center Director.
b. SUNY-Oneonta has a full-time Emergency Management Coordinator.
c. SUNY-Oneonta regularly reviews its crime prevention security analysis for campus buildings.

3. Steger pointed to the fact that, “The university works closely with the Community Service Board in ordering commitments of students in need of immediate counseling (Temporary Detention Orders).” Now take a look at SUNY-Oneonta:

a. Students are given a full security briefing as part of their campus orientation.
b. The Chief of Police has the power to act immediately and to take whatever action he deems necessary if an individual is thought to be a danger to him or herself or others.
c. Each staff and faculty member has at her or his desk a bright orange Crisis Management folder for immediate and easy reference. The folder contains phone numbers and contact instructions.

4. Steger also asserted that, “During an emergency the university can use several notification methods, including VT Alerts. More people within the university have been trained to issue emergency alerts through the university emergency notification system. First-responders can asses the scene and determine whether an immediate alert or notification should be issued by the police department.” Good start, but not enough. Look at SUNY:

a. SUNY-Oneonta has the ability to notify all students, staff, and faculty of an emergency through NY ALERT—a cell phone/email/text messaging system. All New York State University campuses will have this system within the near future.
b. The school is linked to major criminal data bases in Albany.
c. The University Police Department has an ambulance on hand, on campus.
d. It is a state law that university police departments on state-affiliated schools must have a Memorandum of Understanding with the state police on immediate emergency response and actions. SUNY-Oneonta has such a memorandum and maintains close ties with the New York State Police and the city of Oneonta Police Department.

To say that Virginia Tech President Steger’s words are a disappointment is to put it mildly. If he really had the safety of the students, faculty, and staff of the university as his top priority, Virginia Tech would have a far better system of security and emergency response than his words indicate.

Thursday, February 19, 2009

CYNTHIA PARIS—WEAK STORY; WEAK ANALYSIS

Cynthia Paris’ story in the February 15, 2009 edition of the Richmond Times-Dispatch misses the point about Virginia Tech altogether. Frankly, the story was short on substance and long on vague words. Indeed, Ms. Paris’ story has a slightly condescending tone from start to finish. For example: “It isn’t that the newly opened archive of documents is not a good idea. Different perspective will come to light when fresh sets of eyes examine the thousands of notes and e-mails … Such reviews may yield new guidelines for coping (sic) with –God forbid –a comparably horrific future event.” Ms. Paris did you really mean to use a form of the verb to cope? Am I right, are you asking people to learn to cope with the loss of a son or daughter in a school shooting? I won’t even dignify your incredibly poor word choice with a comment.

The point behind the investigation into the Virginia Tech massacre is to learn and put in place measures to help prevent future school shootings; to hold people in positions of authority liable for their actions or inactions. In the case of Virginia Tech, President Steger and the school’s leaders clearly have flunked crisis management, and even worse—the basics of crime scene reaction and response. That is a fact, to ignore that fact is adding insult to injury.

Yes, President Steger should go. I am not a casual observer and I say this not out of a desire for vengeance, but out of the cold, hard facts of the reality of what happened on April 16, 2007. I teach intelligence and crime analysis at all levels of the federal and state governments, as well as for the Canadian Police College. Rarely, if ever, have I seen such incompetence when confronted with a crime scene. That incompetence rests squarely on the shoulders of President Steger. President Steger failed to react when confronted with the initial two murders. He failed to act while other parts of the university were locking down or taking security measures; he failed to act while members of the school administration were warning their family members of the threat.

You are just dead wrong, Ms. Paris. Virginia Tech officials, beginning with the school president, should be held liable for their incredibly poor judgment on the morning of April 16, 2007.

I use the tragedy of Virginia Tech in my classes as an example of what not to do at a crime scene and in crime analysis. Furthermore, Governor Kaine’s review panel report is nearly as badly flawed as the actions of the Virginia Tech leadership. In one sense, the report is more disturbing than Steger’s inaction. If Virginia is to learn from the Tech tragedy, the report needed to be honest, have access to all primary documents, and it needed to be accurate.

The report is none of these. The report engages in the worst sort of word games and sugarcoats reality; the report did not have all the documents it needed (the State Police, ATF, and gun dealers did not allow the panel to access to Cho’s applications to buy weapons); the report’s timeline is badly flawed. If something as elementary to any analytical process as a timeline is not right, how can you believe anything in the report? Ms. Paris, any college student, anywhere, knows the importance of having access to primary documents and the importance of a timeline.

By the end of 2009, I will introduce a case study exercise on Virginia Tech—based on the facts surrounding that tragedy. The case study will also include Governor Kaine’s Review Panel Report. The case study will not gloss over President Steger’s actions nor will it sugarcoat the governor’s report.

Ms. Paris, the April 16, 2007 massacre at Virginia Tech not only happened on President Steger’s watch, his failure to act doomed 30 people. He does need to be held liable for his mistake—liable in every sense of that word.

Friday, February 13, 2009

BASING YOUR CASE ON THE SUFFERINGS OF OTHERS

Losing a child in a school shooting immobilizes you. You have difficulty thinking; you cannot articulate thoughts clearly; the depth of your depression knows no bounds.

It is just at that moment—when you are the weakest—that the gun rights proponents go on the offensive with: “Don’t limit our access to guns, we are law abiding citizens!” “We all have the right to defend ourselves!” Those words are yours not ours. No one says you are not law abiding, no one wants to limit your access to guns. Every single human being has the right to defend himself or herself—there is no debate on that point. But what does that have to do with keeping firearms out of the hands of the mentally ill or unstable? “We cannot take guns away from hunters!” I couldn’t agree more, and most hunters I have talked to in my family and outside agree that the problem is not “hunters,” but individuals who are a danger to themselves or others.

The second amendment advocates’ words blur and obscure the real issue—the problem is to pass laws that keep guns out of the hands of the unfit and mentally ill and yet ensure the right of law abiding citizens to own weapons. The most perplexing aspect of the gun advocates arguments is their willingness to make their points by spreading false arguments. To deliberately deviate from the truth at the expense of shooting victims and their families is unconscionable.

This is specifically what has happened in the case of the shooting at the Appalachian School of law. NRA officials and supporters have spread the word that armed students subdued the gun man on the law school grounds. The fact is that the two students, who went to their cars to retrieve guns, arrived after unarmed students subdued the killer--Peter Odighizuwa. The head of the NRA gave an address in Roanoke several years ago and made the assertion that armed students played the key role in the apprehension of Odighizuwa. A few days later the Roanoke Times ran a rebuttal from a student who witnessed Odighizuwa’s capture, flatly denying the NRA assertion.

Why the NRA would resort to twisting the truth is beyond me. Everything is on their side—they have money, power, and clearly control the Virginia state senate (how else do you explain the fact that the senate killed the bill that would have closed the gun show loophole for buying guns).

For those who stand on soap boxes and beat their chests about the right to own guns; for those who cite the second amendment as the source for doing away with restrictions on the right to own guns—I would remind you that your obstinacy has prevented laws from being enacted that would keep firearms out of the hands of the mentally ill. Both the shooters at the Appalachian School of Law and Virginia Tech were mentally ill. Is this really what you want? You need to make your position clear—otherwise it looks as if you want to make it legal for unstable and potentially violent people to buy guns anywhere, at anytime, without restriction.

I would remind the second amendment proponents that before the Constitution, there was the Declaration of Independence. That document begins with the words, “We hold these truths to be self evident, that all men are created equal and endowed with certain inalienable rights, chief among them the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness.” The founding fathers put the right to “life” before the right to bear arms and certainly before the right to give guns to the mentally unstable. If you don’t have “life,” you cannot have anything guaranteed in the second amendment, the Bill of Rights, or any part of the Constitution.

No victim or group of victims of school shootings can ever compete with the NRA’s power and influence. The NRA is probably the most powerful lobby in Richmond and is the second most powerful lobby in Washington. We simply cannot compete. When was the last time you saw the head of the NRA or one of that organization’s advocates interviewed on television? When was the last time you heard a spokesperson for the victims of gun violence, or a victim interviewed?

One news network, Fox, carries the slogan “fair and balanced” when referring to their standards. It is not uncommon for Fox to interview or host someone representing second amendment rights or the NRA. But, when was the last time you saw a gun control advocate or a shooting victim’s family member on Fox? The few times that I have seen gun control advocates interviewed, the Fox commentators interrupt, challenge, and are openly belligerent. By contrast, when those same commentators interview NRA officials and their supporters, they are respectful, do not interrupt, and never ask pointed questions. The deck is stacked against those of us who are “pro-life for the living.”

Sunday, February 1, 2009

VIRGINIA TECH: LISTEN TO VINCENT

I have just finished reading Vincent Bove’s book, Listen to Their Cries, and I am impressed. The author comes through as a decent man, deeply worried about the flaws in American society—especially the flaws evident in the April 16, 2007 shootings at Virginia Tech.

Some of the words regarding the Tech tragedy are well worth repeating in this blog:

“How is it conceivable that two people are killed on a college campus during the week of the anniversary of Columbine and the killer is at large and (a) lockdown is not immediately called for? Even if it were determined that the first two killings could not have been prevented because of the complexities and confusion surrounding mental health and privacy issues, it is inexcusable that nothing was done to prevent the 30 killings and multiple injuries that occurred two hours later.” (page 80)

“The (Virginia Tech) policy group owes the public a full accounting of their discussions regarding the delay in sending notification and their decision not to immediately lockdown the campus.” (page 81)

“It is unfortunate that at a time when the focus and priority should have been on meeting the needs of the families of those who have died and on the injured victims and their families, university leadership went on a damage control mode and displayed a lack of empathy toward the victims and their families.” (page 81)

“A website in support of President Charles Steger and Police Chief Wendell Flinchum (www.wesupportvt.com) was created within THREE DAYS of the tragedy while the Office of Recovery and Support website (www.recovery.vt.com) for the victims and their families took FOUR MONTHS to get online.” (page 83)

“It is also interesting to note that the university felt it necessary to hire Burson-Marsteller, by some accounts the fifth largest public relations firm IN THE WORLD, to handle communications related to (the) April 16th tragedy. … The engagement of this public relations behemoth must be at a significant cost to the university, since they would not release the details of the contract. Wouldn’t this money be better spent on enhancing safety, security, and recovery activities on campus?” (page 83)

The sections I have quoted are just the highlights of Vincent Bove’s references to Virginia Tech. His book contains broader pointers for campus safety. Indeed, every parent considering sending a son or daughter to an institution of higher learning in Virginia should read Bove’s suggestions on campus security. Parents should grill campus officials and demand to know what security measures are in place.

The sad truth is that while progress has been made in Virginia, our schools are still woefully lacking in the security training, systems, and leadership to make them safe.

All three of our sons attended college and university in Virginia. They got excellent educations. However, if I had known then, what I know now about the poor state of campus security in Virginia I would have sent them elsewhere. I would gladly pay the out-of-state fees to send my children to a school that ranks campus security as a number one priority.

If you are reading this and your son or daughter is considering a Virginia school, think twice. Check the school’s security and safety policy and if not satisfied, tell the school’s administration and admissions departments why you will not allow your child to enroll at that particular college or university; that you will look for another school. If every parent would do that, it will eventually force university and college officials to give campus safety the highest of priorities.

Listen to Vincent Bove. I was particularly struck by his section on Citizens of Character (page 163). I could not help but think that his words apply to many of the people who were in positions of authority at Virginia Tech University on April 16, 2007; especially the quote from President Theodore Roosevelt: “To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society.”

Thursday, January 22, 2009

VIRGINIA TECH: THE DISCREPANCIES, THE QUESTIONS, THE COVER-UP

The second anniversary of the Virginia Tech massacre is drawing near and the truth about what happened that terrible day is blurred in a flog of deceit, half-truths, and outright deception. The sad fact is that Virginia Tech is no safer today than it was on April 15, 2007.

Steger failed to act immediately following the first two shootings at West Amber Johnston. President Steger was told of the shootings by the Virginia Tech Police Chief Flinchum at 8:10am. The stories of the content of that conversation keep changing. At a minimum, Flinchum and other Virginia Tech police officers knew that there was no suspect, no witness, no weapon, and there were bloody footprints leaving the scene. Steger claims he was not aware that there was a person of interest until 8:40am—all the more reason Steger should have acted at 8:10am following his talk with Chief Flinchum.

Governor Kaine’s blue-ribbon investigation does little to clear up the questions and ambiguity about when and what President Steger was told by Chief Flinchum. Indeed, the governor has admitted that the time-line of events in the report is wrong. If something as elementary as a time-line in a criminal investigation is wrong, how can you believe anything in the report?

Steger’s defenders say that he doesn’t deserve the criticism he is getting. They call him a decent and honorable man—I am sure he is. They point to his accomplishments at Virginia Tech as a professor, as the dean of the College of Architecture and Urban Studies, as the vice president of Outreach and Development, and as president—I am sure these accomplishments are many. I would go even further, I am sure that he is a decent man who has devoted his life to educating others. None of this however, negates the fact that he made a crucial error in judgment—he was wrong in not alerting the campus. At that critical moment following the first two shootings he was an incompetent leader—none of his previous accomplishments can negate that fact.

If I made a poor judgment and ran a stop sign causing an accident and the death of 30 people, I could not stand in court and tell the judge I am not responsible because I am a decent person with a track record of many fine accomplishments. I would be held accountable for poor judgment. President Steger needs to be held accountable, he needs to go.

President Steger demonstrated, by his inaction, that he does not deserve to be in a position of leadership; a position that may call on him to make decisions in a crisis situation in the future. He flunked that test; he flunked it badly. No matter how many security systems are put in place to protect a school, if the individual responsible for activating the systems is incompetent, the school is not safe.

President Steger also needs to explain why the Virginia Tech Police Chief was put in for a 51% pay raise. Granted, the governor has frozen pay raises, but the 51% proposal itself needs to be explained. I am sure it is not the case, but the proposed pay raise could give the appearance of an attempt to bring Chief Flinchum into agreement with Steger on when and what the school president was told about the first shootings. Even in the best of times, a 51% pay raise needs an explanation!

Following any crisis of the magnitude of Virginia Tech, rumors abound. The school needs to deal with those rumors and put them to rest. The cutoff date for donations to be included as part of the memorial fund (HSMF) disbursement to the families was August 15th. Donations after that date were placed in the school’s general scholarship fund. That date, and the determination of the amount of donations intended for the families vs. the amount intended for the school, was established solely by Virginia Tech. The families had no say in the amount of money they were to get or the cut-off date. But what is most disturbing are unsubstantiated reports that individuals in the school’s administration quietly advised donors not to make their contributions until after August 15th . If true, this would go beyond disturbing, it would be disgusting and despicable. I really cannot think of words to accurately describe such actions. Please President Steger, please Virginia Tech, clear this up.


The one thing that the Virginia Tech families need is the truth. Their lives will never move back toward any degree of normalcy until all the questions are answered. President Steger’s unwillingness to admit his role in the tragedy as well as Governor Kaine’s apparent unwillingness to thoroughly reexamine the details of the shootings, point to either indifference to the families’ suffering, incompetence, or a cover-up.

When you couple the above with the fact that the Virginia Police “declined” to turn over pertinent documents related to Cho’s purchase of weapons, you are left gasping for air and wondering what kind of Orwellian world do we live in? The victims’ families and the residents of Virginia still need a thorough and complete explanation of what went on.

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

VIRGINIA TECH: THANK YOU DAVID RESS

Thank you David Ress, and the Richmond Times-Dispatch, for your investigative reporting on Virginia Tech, and for your tenacity in trying to get to the bottom of that tragedy. I hope you and your newspaper will keep digging to find the truth. Please don’t listen to the nay-sayers who want to “move on.”

We cannot “move on” and feel that our schools are safe until all the information and facts about Virginia Tech are made public. We cannot “move on” until those who showed incredibly bad judgment, such as university President Steger, are removed from office. We cannot “move on” until the university releases all the documents related to the shooting. We cannot “move on” until the police agree to cooperate and turn over all documents related to Cho’s purchase of weapons.

As long as university and police officials refuse to be 100 percent cooperative in the investigation of the events of April 16, 2007, any report or analysis of that tragedy will be woefully lacking, if not dishonest. Keep digging David Ress, keep digging.