Saturday, June 27, 2009

CHANGE OF VENUE; LOSS OF JUSTICE

When Fairfax County Circuit Judge Charles Maxfield decided, on June 11, 2009, to grant the defendants’ motion to change the venue of the trial dealing with the Virginia Tech shootings, he may have dealt a mortal blow to the search for truth. Moving the trial from Fairfax County in northern Virginia to Montgomery County (where the school is located) almost certainly assures conflict of interest and bias against the plaintiffs.

To understand the conflict of interest, you have to understand how Virginia’s judges are chosen. Each county in Virginia has a General Circuit Court, and Circuit Court judges are elected to eight year terms by the Virginia General Assembly. Delegate David Nutter of the 7th House District (which includes part of Montgomery County) and Delegate Jim Shuler of the 12th House District (which includes the town of Blacksburg and much of Virginia Tech itself) are both graduates of the school. The two men-co-authored a major OpEd piece in the Richmond Times-Dispatch on March 18, 2009 strongly supporting Tech President Charles Steger, one of the defendants in the lawsuit.

Both Delegate Nutter and Delegate Shuler play roles in the selection of Circuit Court judges in Blacksburg. Therefore, the judge who will hear the case most likely holds his or her position—in part—to two politicians who are on record as strongly supporting Charles Steger and the school against any charges of wrong-doing or incompetence. If this is not a blatant conflict of interest, I do not know what is. Furthermore, Virginia Tech is the largest employer in that part of the state—the school wields enormous power and influence—both economic and political. One has to ask, “Can objectivity stand up to such overwhelming strength to suppress the search for truth?”

Judge Maxfield, how could you miss this point? If you were going to allow a change of venue, why did you agree to a change that raises the specter of corruption of the legal process?

Equally as troubling as the decision to move the trial, is the wording of Judge Maxfield’s decision. The Judge’s reads:

ORDER
On the 11th day of June, 2009, came the parties, by counsel, to be heard on the Defendant’s Motion to Transfer Venue of this mater to the Circuit Court of Montgomery County pursuant to Va. Code 8.01-265.

UPON CONSIDERATION WHEREOF, the court finds that good cause to transfer this action to Montgomery Count pursuant to Va. Code 8.01-265 exist because transfer to that venue would avoid substantial inconvenience to the parties and witnesses in this action.

IT IS ORDERED that venue be, and the same hereby is, transferred to the Circuit Court of Montgomery County, to which action of the Court Plaintiff, by counsel objected and excepted.

ENTERED: 6/11/09

Signed: C. Maxfield
Circuit Court Judge

The judge’s words raise questions. The use of the word “inconvenience” is especially troubling. The dictionary defines inconvenience as “1. Lack of ease or comfort; trouble; difficulty. 2. Something that causes difficulty, trouble, or discomfort; an inconvenient thing.” A convincing argument for a change of venue would have included the word “hardship” for the defendants—that word never appears. The families of the Virginia Tech murder victims have not had “ease” or “comfort” for over two years, they are “troubled,” they are having “difficulty” getting their lives back in order. But, Judge Maxfield doesn’t want the defendants to “lack ease or comfort,” or to be caused any “difficulty” or be “troubled.”

Words not only have their dictionary meanings, but the have connotations and members of the legal profession are trained in the use of words—they are sensitive to the actual and implied meanings of words. I have first-hand class room experience in this fact, I have taught dozens of lawyers in Intelligence analysis and writing. I have seen first hand their skill and knowledge in the use of words. The tone of “inconvenience” is at best disappointing. It is condescending and brushes aside the legitimacy of the families’ desire to leave no stone unturned to find answers and seek redress. I am finding it hard to accept that Judge Maxfield was not aware of the baggage the word “inconvenience” carries.

I am also concerned that the inconvenience to the victims’ families was blithely set aside. The families of the dead students and professors will be “inconvenienced” for the rest of their lives. The families of the victims will never stop wondering what could have been, what would my child have become? Now, thanks to Judge Maxfield’s ruling, the victims families will be inconvenienced even further.

Our children embody the meaning of life itself. In the final analysis, our children are our greatest and most valuable possessions—they give us meaning. Judge Maxfield’s decision is painful because he may have denied the Virginia Tech parents their right to a fair and honest day in court.

I was teaching an Intelligence writing course in northern Virginia when Judge Maxfield’s decision was made. During the class, one of the students asked me for an example of poor decisions by people in authority and poor analytical writing. My response was to cite Judge Maxfield’s decision to move the venue of the trial to Montgomery county, and Governor Kaine’s acceptance of the badly flawed report on the shootings at Virginia Tech.

One of the students, a former military intelligence officer who was recently in Iraq putting his life on the line in defense of this country and in support of our struggle against terrorism, asked a disturbing question: “Did you really expect the legal system or the Governor’s report to do anything but engage in a cover-up?”
His question stopped me dead in my tracks. I could only wonder, is that what the men and women in Iraq and Afghanistan think they are fighting for—cover-ups? I could only answer, “Given the magnitude of the crime committed on April 16, 2007, I thought Virginians everywhere—politicians, school officials, law enforcement officers, and members of the legal profession—would come together to find the truth. I was wrong. Judge Maxfield’s decision may be the most telling example of just how wrong I have been.”

(Blogger’s Note: Is anyone else upset over the student’s comment? After all the hype over our involvement in Iraq; after all the politicians’ chest-beating about bring democracy and rule-by-law to the Middle East, a young man who has put his life on the line for these goals expects our system of justice to be corrupt when it comes to this nation’s worst school shooting.)

It is a simple fact that if people and institutions are not held accountable for their actions and inactions, our schools will not be safe. There will be no incentive for the Charles Steger’s of this world to take action when confronted with threats, unless they realize they will pay a price—they will be forced to explain themselves, under oath in a court of law, and if that explanation is not satisfactory, they will—at minimum—lose their jobs.

The Fairfax County Circuit Court does not want the defendants to be inconvenienced, but for the parents and families of the Virginia Tech shooting, the inconvenience of the agony of their loss will be with them the rest of their lives. The victims’ families will spend the rest of their time on this earth trying to make something out of what held so much promise, what could have been.

Friday, June 12, 2009

VIRGINIA TECH: COLD, CALCULATING

Mistakes in judgment often are understandable and become regrets because they were honest and made in the heat of the moment. However, in the case of Virginia Tech, it seems clear that many of the decisions made in the wake of the horrors of April 16, 2007, were not mistakes in judgment; they were cold, calculating decisions designed to protect the school’s leaders and reputation. All available evidence indicates the school put damage control ahead of the interests of the victims’ families and ahead of school safety.

Within three days of the shootings, a Web site (www.wesupportvt.com) in support of President Charles Steger and Chief Wendell Finchum was created. By contrast, it took Virginia Tech’s Office of Recovery and Support four months to get the Web site (www.recoveryvt.com) for the victims’ families up and running.

Less than six weeks after the shootings, on May 29, 2007, Virginia Tech signed a contract with one of this country’s largest and most prestigious publication firms—Burson-Marsteller—to handle publicity about the shooting rampage. (And no doubt, to put the school, President Steger, and Chief Finchum in the best light, by focusing public attention away from the administration’s glaring mistakes in judgment and on “the Hokie nation’s” need to pull together and recover.)

Monies paid to Burson-Marsteller totaled $663,006.48. This, in spite of the fact that Virginia Tech has a university public relations office staffed by highly competent officials—as well as courses in public relations taught by outstanding faculty members—yet the school paid nearly $700,000.00 to a public relations firm to spin the shooting tragedy. Burson-Marsteller came to prominence in the 1990s for organizing a campaign in support of Philip Morris and the tobacco industry focused on smokers’ rights. (Do I see a tie to some of the most powerful groups in Virginia?) Later, they played spin-doctor again for Dow-Corning’s campaign on behalf of silicone breast implants. Some silicone implants developed leaks once implanted in a woman’s body, causing serious health problems. Can there be any other conclusion that Burson-Marsteller was engaged by Virginia Tech to continue working the magic of misdirection in their client’s favor?

Compare the $663.006.48 of tax payers’ money spend on public relations with the $100,000.00 awarded to each of the dead victims’ families. A paltry $100,000.00 compensation for the loss of a child is a disgrace and an insult. Paying a huge amount of money to a public relations firm only adds insult to injury. The math is lousy; the math says it all. The school’s judgment and priorities were badly misplaced. The nearly $700,000.00 would have been better spent had it been given to the grieving families to help in the recovery process—counseling, etc. Or, the money should have been spent on school security as a tribute to the victims.

On March 18, 2009, an OpEd article of mine appeared in the Richmond Times-Dispatch. The article called for Virginia Tech President Charles Steger to step down and for Governor Kaine to reopen the investigation into the Tech shootings. A few days later, I received a well-written, thoughtful response from a lawyer in New York. He wrote, “While there are many bright, highly competent and well-intentioned people working in higher education, there is also a high level of mediocrity, incompetence and self-interest. In my opinion the latter traits have been displayed in this situation at Virginia Tech. And, such traits have been excused and ratified by the Governor’s immediate political actions in this instance.”

My family is part of the Hokie Nation. Our youngest son, Richard, is a graduate of Virginia Tech. We are so proud of the outstanding education he received at Virginia Tech, and we always have been. However, that pride does not preclude the shame we feel over the school’s abysmal leadership—specifically, the school’s cold, calculating actions designed to protect and enhance the Virginia Tech image at the expense of the victims’ families.

Friday, May 8, 2009

NEW LAWSUIT; NEW HOPE

On April 16, 2009 the families of Julia Kathleen Pryde and Erin Nicole Peterson, two victims of the Virginia Tech shooting, filed a lawsuit in the Fairfax County Virginia Circuit Court against the school and its employees, the state, and the estate of gunman Seung-Hui Cho. The lawsuit alleges gross negligence and seeks $10 million in compensation.

The Pryde and Peterson families issued a statement explaining their actions and why they did not go along with the other victims’ family in reaching an out-of-court settlement. The two families said they declined to go along with the earlier settlement because they did not have all the facts on the handling of the shooting. The press quoted the Pryde and Peterson families as saying, “We believe that our suit is necessary to reveal truths that ultimately will benefit all those who have shared in this tragic loss.” The following is the statement issued by the two families explaining their actions:

“We raised our daughters with a sense of integrity, a desire to seek the truth and a belief in keeping their word. Virginia Tech did not keep its word to us. We have filed this lawsuit in the hope that we will receive accountability for the tragic events of April 16, 2007.”

“The faculty and students of Virginia Tech have been extremely supportive of the families during this difficult time. Erin and Julia loved Virginia Tech and they felt at home there and were receiving a wonderful education. But, on April 16, 2007 the administrators who ran the university let our daughters down in ways we are just now learning.”

“Sadly, the Report of the (Virginia Tech) Review Panel to the Governor, issued in August 2007, contained important inaccuracies, despite the panel’s best efforts to get to the truth. University officials, it now appears, may have been less than candid and forthright in their responses to the questions put to them by the panel.”

The two families’ statement hits the nail on the head—there are important inaccuracies, and university officials apparently were less than candid and forthright in their responses to the panel. Indeed, the new lawsuit may be the last best chance to find the truth and hold individuals accountable for their inexplicably poor judgment. If this lawsuit comes to trial:

1. The inaccuracies of timeline of events will be exposed and corrected.

2. President Steger, Chief Flinchum, and others will be put under oath and forced to reveal the content of their conversations and actions on the morning of April 16, 2007 following the first two killings.

3. The gun dealer, the ATF, and the state police will be required to turn over documents related to Cho’s weapons purchase—something they have so far refused to do.

4. The members of the school administration will be forced to reveal what they were told and when.

5. University officials will be forced to explain why some on the campus took security measures and locked down and others did not.

6. Members of the school’s Policy Group will have to explain why they felt the situation was serious enough to warn their family members, but not the rest of the school.

The Review Panel’s report was a factor in the out-of-court settlement by 30 Virginia Tech families. If the new lawsuit should prove that in any way that school officials deliberately misled the governor’s review panel, what are the implications for the 30 families who have already settled? Is that settlement null and void if it is based on faulty information; if the families were deliberately deceived? Can individuals be held accountable for making misleading statements? Could individuals be found guilty of obstruction of justice for withholding information from the Governor’s Review Panel?

The preceding questions come into sharper focus when you look at some of the details of the new law suit’s formal complaint:

1. Virginia Tech issued a release which obfuscated the fact that there had been a double homicide in a dormitory in the early morning of April 16, 2007; diluted any information to that effect; implied that there were not serious injuries or deaths in the shooting incident; and further implied that the incident was a completed event, that there was no gunman at large who was armed and dangerous and potentially on campus, and there was need for anyone on campus to take specific precautions for their own safety.

2. As an inadequate warning, it constituted no warning at all, and in a sense artificially reassured the students, faculty and employees that whatever occurred in West Amber Johnston Hall that morning was of much lesser consequences and risks than either the Morva incident or the two recent threatened bombings on the engineering campus. The language, content and lack of specificity of the alert clearly implied that there was no reason to take any specific action for one’s own safety.

3. In May, 2002, the United States Secret Service and the United States Department of Education issued their report: Threat Assessment in Schools: A Guide to Managing Threatening Situations and to Creating Safe School Climates. Research led to an inescapable conclusion: the first line of safety for students, faculty and employees is detection of those students who pose a risk of harm to fellow students, teachers or school employees. The published studies set out a list of early warning signs (and response to those signs. But,) as of October, 2005 and up to April 16, 2007, Virginia Tech had no threat assessment process, no threat assessment team, not threat assessment policies, protocols or plans. Had Virginia Tech followed this roadmap laid out in the report, Seung-Hui Cho would have been identified as a student at risk.

4. The records of Cho’s visit to the Cook Counseling Center and the records made by others and accumulated at the Cook Counseling Center with respect to Cho were required by Virginia law to be maintained. They were not… The absence of any records of Cho’s contacts with his adjudication of mental illness and dangerousness, the absence of records of his voluntary and involuntary order into out-patient therapy based upon that illness, … reflects the continued consequences of the negligence and gross negligence of the officers, agents, and employees of the Cook Counseling Center.

5. On April 16, 2007, the duly authorized agents of the university, seduced by the prospect of a successful fund drive, and driven to control the message of the morning of April 16th in fulfillment of that ambition and to protect the general reputation and image of the university, behaved in a deliberately indifferent way to the safety of the university’s students and faculty, (and) failed to warn them of the risks inherent in allowing a gunman who had already killed two to run loose on the campus.

It is my sincere hope that the Virginia Tech families will finally get the answers to all their questions. There is a saying that “to get over tragedy, you first have to accept that you will never get over it.” Based on our experience with the shooting at the Appalachian School of Law shootings, I know that to be true. But, in order to come to terms with the Virginia Tech tragedy, in order to move on with life, the truth about every aspect of that crime needs to be made public. Truth is the one thing the families of the victims need more than anything else. The new law suit is probably the last best way to find truth, to find peace, and to find justice—all of which, so far have been elusive.

Sunday, May 3, 2009

WHAT ARE THEY HIDING?

On April 22-23, 2009, I had the honor and privilege to speak to approximately 150 police intelligence officers from all over the U.S., Europe, Latin America, and Africa. The occasion was the international conference of the International Association of Law Enforcement Intelligence Agencies (I.A.L.E.I.A) in Las Vegas, Nevada.

I spoke about analytic thinking and written analysis, with an emphasis on the ethics of intelligence analysis. This year, I used part of my presentation to dissect Governor Kaine’s Review Panel Report on the mass killings at Virginia Tech. Although some may not view the report as intelligence, it is in every sense of the word. The report is a finished intelligence product centering on crime scene analysis. An intelligence report should be based on the following principles: Accuracy, access to all available sources of information, clarity of thought, solid logic and reasoning, precision of thought and words, and sound conclusions and judgments based on the evidence.

I picked my words carefully and spoke with a certain amount of hesitation. My comments, after all, were (and are) critical of law enforcement officials, politicians, and school leaders. Among the topics I touched on were:

1. The report’s flawed timeline—this flaw violates the principle of accuracy.

2. The report’s failure to have all sources of information, most notably the refusal of the police, the ATF, and gun dealers to turn over key documents related to Cho’s purchase of weapons—this flaw violates the principles of both accuracy and having access to all sources of information.

3. The report’s wholesale use of word games and obfuscations: Specifically, the report states on page 71, that “…under federal law, Cho could not purchase any firearm.” Earlier, on page 7, the report says, “Finally, with respect to Cho’s firearms purchases, the Virginia State Police, the ATF, and the gun dealers each declined to provide the panel with copies of the applications Cho completed when he bought his weapons or of other records relating to any background check that may have occurred in connection with those purchases. The Virginia State Police, however, did describe the contents of Cho’s gun purchase applications to members of the panel and its staff.” The difference between these two entries in the report are never reconciled—page 71 flatly asserts that Cho could not, under federal law, buy any firearm—yet he did, and the documentation of those purchases was withheld from the review panel. This flaw violates every principle of not only good intelligence writing, but good academic analytical work—most notably, clarity of thought as well as solid logic and reasoning.

4. The report’s failure to identify critical errors in judgment on the part of school and law enforcement officials following the first two killings at West Amber Johnston Hall—specifically, the lack of any clear account of what Chief Flinchum told Virginia Tech President Charles Steger and other university officials, and why parts of the campus took precautionary measures and others did not. This failure is a thinly veiled effort to avoid assigning accountability and responsibility to anyone or group of people for bad judgment. This flaw violates a number of principles including accuracy and failure to make sound conclusions and judgments from the evidence.

I was not sure what the response would be, but to my surprise the reaction was uniformly and overwhelmingly supportive. Those who came up to me immediately after the session and during the rest of the conference invariably asked, “What are school and state officials in Virginia hiding?”

Many officers told me stories of attempted cover-ups in their home states. One officer said that a prosecuting attorney actually told him to lie about a crime scene because “the facts did not fit his theory of the case.” The officer did not lie and the judge threw the case out.

I would never accuse anyone in the Virginia Tech school administration, in the governor’s mansion, or in law enforcement agencies of lying—that would be beyond the pale; that would be the unthinkable. For anyone to be dishonest and lie when dealing with the worst school shooting in this nation’s history—well, I don’t think we have a word or words in the English language to describe such actions.

I do, however, disagree strongly with the content, or should I say lack of content, of Governor Kaine’s report. In order to do away with any impression that this report is inaccurate, the investigation needs to be reopened and all the documents and facts need to be available to those investigating the crime. There is only one way to prevent these school shootings and that is to examine them with brutal honesty and hold individuals accountable.

Sunday, April 5, 2009

A TRIBUTE TO ANGELA DENISE DALES

On April 2, 2009, Virginia Intermont College hosted a tribute to Angela Dales, an alumna of the class of 1991, who was killed in the January 16, 2002 shooting at the Appalachian School of Law. Lori Haas, whose daughter was wounded in the Virginia Tech shootings on April 16, 2009, joined us. We addressed a gathering of students, staff, and faculty. A reception and book signing followed the presentations. The following are my remarks:

Let me begin by thanking Virginia Intermont and specifically, Ronan King, for arranging this presentation and book signing. Today is a wonderful tribute to Angela Dales. She loved this school and today she would be so proud of what is taking place on this campus. She spoke of the school frequently—always in glowing terms. Even after graduating, she frequently came back to the Virginia Intermont to see members of the faculty and staff whom she counted among her dearest friends.

It was at Virginia Intermont where Angela Dales and our son, David, met and fell in love. It was on these school grounds that they planned their future together, that they told each other their hopes and dreams. It was on this campus that Angela Dales practiced one of her passions: writing. Her poems appeared in your literary journal, she dreamed of writing the great American novel. I am so deeply sorry to be here today with a book that is about her, rather than by her. I am so sorry that we have to meet to discuss the violence that plagues our campuses—that has robbed scores of young people of their hopes, their dreams, and their lives.

By attending today’s session you are honoring her memory and that honor means so much to my wife and me, as well as to Angie’s parents—Sue and Danny Dales who are here today.

The greatest tribute we can pay to Angela Dales and all the victims of school shootings is to re-double our efforts to make our campuses safer. Hopefully, in colleges and universities--in forums such as this--we can come together and begin to take control of this problem. We must have the strength to meet this problem head-on; we must have the will and determination to examine this violence; to root out its causes. No matter how painful it is, we cannot shy away from the task that faces all of us—to make our schools safer.

The sad truth is that seven years after the shooting at the Appalachian School of Law and nearly two years after the tragedy at Virginia Tech, Virginia’s colleges and universities are still not as safe as they need to be. The problem is so immense that at times it is overwhelming.

Let me quote from a poignant and compelling article in the Denver Post, by Mike Littwin following the recent shootings in Alabama and Germany. Mr. Littwin has covered the all-to-many school shootings beginning with Columbine. “And if there’s one lesson to take from Columbine, it is that whatever happens, we never seem to learn anything. That’s how we come to meet again at the intersection where disturbed young men turn into psychopaths with access to guns. … Years (after Columbine), after too many massacres, the killings are treated more like natural phenomena—they come, like tsunamis, (they come in giant waves of horror and sweep over us) and then drift from our consciousness, leaving death and sorrow in their wake.”

“In each new town, the same story emerges—the flowers, the poems, the candles, the turn to religion, the questions about a just God, the young people learning far too young the meaning of tragedy.”

Unfortunately, Mr. Littwin’s words are all too true, but we cannot treat these shootings as natural phenomena. These shootings are anything but natural. They are an abomination, and they are occurring with such regularity that they are no longer phenomena.

The simple fact remains that until individuals who are in charge; until people who are in control, understand that if they ignore clear warning signs and end up costing the lives of students, staff, or faculty members, they will pay a price, they will lose their jobs. Furthermore, until both houses of the Virginia legislature adopt laws that ensure that individuals who are a threat to themselves and others are treated and that weapons are kept out of those individuals’ hands—Virginia’s schools are not safe. Virginia voters should remove legislators who shy away from their duties to help ensure the safety of our schools.

There are three words that capture what I am trying to say. I am talking about three words that are spoken in every court room in this land, every day: responsibility, accountability, and liability.

The parallels in both school shootings—the Appalachian School of Law and
Virginia Tech—are staggering. The litany of human failings in both tragedies knows no bounds. We learn nothing by glossing over these short-comings; we dishonor the dead students and faculty members by shying away from reality; from the fact that those two tragedies took 35 innocent live and wounded scores of others.

We can engage in intellectual debates about the interpretation of this or that law; we can argue over what the founding fathers meant to guarantee in the second amendment—but the simple fact is that there can be no campus safety until school officials, law enforcement personnel, and politicians are held responsible for both their actions and inactions. While these intellectual debates have gone on, lives have been lost.

Poor decisions by good people are not an acceptable defense in a court room or anywhere else—especially when those poor decisions have catastrophic results. If I made a poor decision and ran a stop sign resulting and in the deaths of 30 people, I could not stand in front of a judge and say that I am a decent man who has done wonderful things throughout his life and therefore I should not be held liable or accountable for my poor judgment and what happened. Yet this is exactly what has happened here in Virginia in the cases of both the Appalachian School of Law and Virginia Tech.

Ignoring the Warning Signs or Failing to Act

The Appalachian School of Law: A few weeks before the shooting, three female staff members’ complaints about the shooter, Peter Odighizuwa, were brought before the school’s “core administrative staff.” That staff included school President Ellsworth, Dean Anthony Sutin, and Associate Dean Paul Lund. Documents in the Wise County, Virginia Court House contain President Ellsworth’s words in brushing the complaints aside: “You women and your hormones and your women’s intuition……There is nothing you women need to be afraid of….It will be ok.” A few weeks after that meeting Dean Sutin, Professor Blackwell and student Angela Dales lay dead from Odighizuwa’s bullets.

Virginia Tech University: The warning signs concerning Seung Hui Cho’s unstable and potentially violent nature were just as evident. Indeed, we could spend the full hour listing the warnings signs at Virginia Tech.

I will only say that in the fall of 2005, Cho’s writings in Professor Nikki Giovanni’s “Creative Writing: Poetry” class were so dark and menacing that students dropped out. Professor Giovanni contacted the Dean of the English department saying that unless Cho was removed from the class, she would resign.

In the spring of 2006, Cho wrote a paper for a creative writing class concerning a young man who hated the students at his school and planmed to kill them and himself.

You have to ask, how many warning do people in positions of authority need before they will act?

While some of you may argue that hindsight is 20-20. I would argue that hindsight is foresight—the signs cannot be ignored. The lessons from the Appalachian School of Law were ignored, making a Virginia Tech inevitable. The lessons from Virginia Tech are currently being ignored.

The State Police Refused to Turn Over Key Documents in Both Cases:

As long as law enforcement officials refuse to turn over documents central to finding out what led up to these tragedies, we can never learn. In the words of one of the nation’s leading authorities on campus security and violence in the workplace—such a refusal is disgusting.

In the case of the Appalachian School of Law, Angela Dales received threatening email several months before she was murdered. The email was in clear violation of both state and federal laws. The school and police failed to thoroughly investigate the email and the sender was never identified. Yet following the shooting, the police asserted the email had nothing to do with the school shooting. If you don’t know who sent the email, how can you make such an assertion? Furthermore, the police refused to let the dead student’s family look at the investigative report. The police did promise to read its content to the family and answer questions. Seven years later the family is still waiting for that to happen.

I turned the threatening email over to the FBI. A special agent was aghast saying the email showed all signs of a serial killer and was upset that the Virginia State Police never turned it over to the FBI. The special agent immediately turned the email over to the FBI unit that was the inspiration for The Silence of the Lambs.

In the case of VirginiaTech, the Virginia State Police, the ATF and the gun dealers each refused to provide the Governor’s Review Panel with copies of the applications Cho completed when he bought his weapons or other records relating to any background check that may have done in connection with these purchases. The most horrific school shooting in this country’s history and the state police, the ATF, and the gun dealers refuse to cooperate! This is disgraceful. The Virginia State Police did, however, DESCRIBE the contents of Cho’s gun purchases to members of the panel and its staff.

Flawed or No Analysis of the Two Shootings

We will never learn if we do not analyze these tragedies, learn from that analysis, and turn those lesson into practice. In the case of the Appalachian School of Law no analysis was ever done. An opportunity was lost, an opportunity that might have helped identify Seung Hui Cho as a threat to himself and others.

In the case of Virginia Tech, the blue-ribbon panel established by Governor Kaine was badly flawed from the outset.

1. The panel was impeded in its work by FOIA rules that did not allow more than two members to meet together or speak by phone without it being considered a public meeting—bureaucracy at its worst.

2. The report did not address issues that needed to be addressed such as identifying mistakes in judgment and the individuals who should be held accountable for their actions or inactions.

3. The panel itself was a prime example of conflict of interest and/or bias. Former Homeland Secretary Tom Ridge publicly stated before the panel convened that the tragedy could not have been prevented—if that is not a bias, I don’t know what is. To suggest that a state panel investigating the activities of a state organization and state employees will be objective is sheer folly. And, there is the state’s appointed representative on the panel—the fact that the families did not select their representative does not speak well for the panel’s objectivity.

4. The final report itself engages in word games; sugar-coating glaring errors. For example the report divides its findings and recommendations into two categories: “What was done well, and what could have been done better.”

SUNY-Oneonta—Excellent Security

Security on Virginia’s college campuses is woefully lacking—particularly when compared to schools in other states. The state university system in New York, for example, has a system that could serve as a model for Virginia. I have copies of that security system and program with me, if any of you would like a copy. I will only say that they can lock down all campus buildings with four strokes on a computer key board, and there are security cameras in all the buildings.

If every school in this country had as well thought out and run security plan as the one at Oneonta, our school grounds would be a far, far safer place. I will give you just one example of what the university system in New York has done—with the stroke of four fingers on a computer keyboard, they can lock down all buildings on their campus. I have copies of the program that is already in place in New York.

A Looming Crisis

The points that I have just raised with you in connection with the
shootings at the Appalachian School of Law and Virginia Tech are, in many respects, part of a far broader crisis we face in this country—a crisis centering on a lack of ethical behavior.

The actions of school officials, law enforcement officers, and politicians in dealing with the events before, during, and after both school shootings here in Virginia may not have been illegal, but they were unethical and morally unconscionable. Indeed, some scholars point to a growing crisis of ethics in this country. I think they are correct. I quote from a book on ethics by Rushworth Kidder, How Good People Make Tough Choices. He says this, “In a society lacking ethics, trust drains away faster than rainfall in a desert. Without trust, there is no basis for agreement … Without trust, in other words, there is no way for any sort of human relations to be sustained.”

Those of us who have analyzed the two terrible school shootings here in Virginia come away with a lack of trust in what we are told, a lack of trust in the disingenuous expressions of support and sympathy, and certainly a lack of trust and confidence in people who are supposed to keep our schools safe.

That same book gives these alarming statistics—people who admit to cheating in their intended specialties:

Law schools: 63 percent

Arts programs: 64 percent

Public service and government programs: 66 percent

With these statistics is any wonder that we have a report analyzing the Virginia Tech massacre that engages in wholesale obfuscation and double-talk? This report is bias. It skews and sugar coats the evidence, and it does not ask (much less answer) the right questions. I cannot help but speculate that some of those who produced the governor’s report on Virginia Tech were in the 60 percentile that Kidder is referring to.

In the final analysis, however, the most sophisticated security system is only as good as the people in charge, the best psychological counseling is only as good as the individuals doing the testing, and the best contingency or emergency plans are only as good as the people who implement them.

CONCLUSION: None of us in the room has the answer to these horrific crimes—there is no one answer—but it is in forums such as this one at Virginia Intermont College that we can begin to find ways to make our campus and school grounds safer. For that reason I want to express my deep and sincere gratitude and thanks to Virginia Intermont College, Ronan King, and all of you who took time to come here.

Eight days ago I sat in the law library of the College of William & Mary on a panel discussing violence on campuses. I was in Thomas Jefferson’s college. Jefferson drafted one of the greatest documents in history—The Declaration of Independence. That document contains these words, “We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable Rights that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness…” Thomas Jefferson, a great American, a founding father, a native Virginian, and graduate of the College of William and Mary, put the right to live at the forefront of thoughts and words, the right to life is an unalienable right, a right that came before the Constitution, a right that came before the Bill of Rights.

We must hold people in positions of authority responsible, accountable, and liable for their actions—until we do, our unalienable right to life will not be guaranteed. We must begin to take control of this problem. Thank you so much for honoring Angela Denise Dales. If she were here today she would be so moved by your tribute. With those words I thank you and I close.

Friday, March 27, 2009

WILLIAM & MARY PANEL TERROR ON CAMPUS

“TERROR ON CAMPUS: SECURITY AND PRIVACY AFTER VIRGINIA TECH”


On March 24, 2009, I was pleased to participate in a panel discussion at the College of William & Mary Law School. Other members of the panel were:


Donald Chalis, Chief of Police, College of William & Mary.


R. Kelly Crace, Counseling Center, College of William & Mary.


Rebecca Hulse, Senior Lecturer in Law, William & Mary Law School and
Assistant Director, Privacy and Technology, Center for Legal and Court
Technology (a joint program of William & Mary Law School and the National
Center for State Courts)


The panel was moderated by Professor Paul Marcus, Haynes Professor of Law and Kelly Professor of Teaching Excellence, and hosted by James Heller, Director of the William & Mary Law Library who arranged the panel. Each speaker was given eight minutes, and as often happens at such events, I ended up with far more to say than I had time to say it in. So I’ve decided to post my complete thoughts here, so that will be available to anyone who is interested in further information on the topic.


REMARKS BY DAVID CARIENS, JR.


I want to thank the William & Mary Law School for hosting this session. It is exactly in forums such as this one that Virginians can discuss and hopefully take the initial steps toward making our schools safer.

The title of this panel is “Terror on Campus: Security and Privacy on Our Campuses after Virginia Tech.” Unfortunately seven years after the murders at the Appalachian School of Law in Grundy, Virginia, and nearly two years after the massacre at Virginia Tech, students, faculty and staff on Virginia campuses are not as safe as they need to be.

The simple fact remains that until individuals who are in charge; until people who are in control understand that if they ignore clear warning signs costing the lives, they will pay a price, they will lose their jobs. Furthermore, until both houses of the Virginia legislature adopt laws that ensure that individuals who are a threat to themselves and others, receive treatment, and that weapons are kept out of those individuals’ hands—Virginia’s schools are not safe. Virginia voters should remove legislators who shy away from their duties to help ensure the safety of our schools.

There are three words that capture what I am trying to say and those three words are all around us in this building. We are in the law library of one of the best and most prestigious schools in this country. I am talking about three words that appear in almost every volume in this building; three words that are spoken in every court room in this land, every day: responsibility, accountability, and liability.

The parallels in both school shootings—the Appalachian School of Law and
Virginia Tech—are staggering. The litany of human failings in both tragedies knows no bounds. We learn nothing by glossing over these shortcomings, and we dishonor the dead students and faculty members by shying away from reality. The fact that these two tragedies took 35 innocent live and wounded scores of others.

We can engage in intellectual debates about the interpretation of this or that law; we can argue over what the founding fathers meant to guarantee in the second amendment—but the simple fact is that there can be no campus safety until school officials, law enforcement personnel, and politicians are held responsible for both their actions and inactions. While these intellectual debates have gone on, lives have been lost.

Ignoring the Warning Signs or Failing to Act

The Appalachian School of Law: A few weeks before the shooting, three female staff members’ complaints about the shooter, Peter Odighizuwa, were brought before the school’s “core administrative staff.” That staff included school President Ellsworth, Dean Anthony Sutin, and Associate Dean Paul Lund. Documents in the Wise County, Virginia Court House contain President Ellsworth’s words in brushing the complaints aside: “You women and your hormones and your women’s intuition……There is nothing you women need to be afraid of….It will be ok.” A few weeks after that meeting Dean Sutin, Professor Blackwell and student Angela Dales lay dead from Odighizuwa’s bullets.

Before that meeting Odighizuwa had pushed a professor away from a podium and taken over a class; he had threatened the school librarian; he had gotten into fights with other students; and he was banded from the Student Service’s Center without an escort because Center employees feared for their safety.

Virginia Tech University: The warning signs concerning Seung Hui Cho’s unstable and potentially violent nature were just as evident.

In November 2005, a year and a half before the killings, a female student filed a complaint with the Virginia Tech Police indicating that Cho had made “annoying” contact with her on the Internet, by phone, and in person. In December of that year another female student complained about Cho’s instant messages and that he went in disguise to, and entered a female student’s room. That same month a magistrate issued a temporary restraining order and Cho was transported to Carilion St. Albans Psychiatric Hospital for an overnight stay and evaluation. A staff psychiatrist determined Cho was not a threat to himself or to others, but did recommend outpatient counseling.

In the fall of 2005, Cho’s writings in Professor Nikki Giovanni’s “Creative Writing: Poetry” class were so dark and menacing that students dropped out. Professor Giovanni contacted the Dean of the English department saying unless Cho was removed form the class, she would resign.

In the spring of 2006, Cho wrote a paper for a creative writing class concerning a young man who hates the students at his school and plans to kill them and himself.

During the fall of 2006, two professors alert school officials about Cho’s abnormal behavior and recommend counseling--Professor Lisa Norris, a writing professor and Professor Falco, another writing professor.

While some of you may argue that hindsight is 20-20. I would argue that hindsight is foresight—as long as the signs are not ignored.

The State Police Refused to Turn Over Key Documents in Both Cases

As long as law enforcement officials refuse to turn over documents central to finding out what led up to these tragedies, we can never learn. In the words of one of the nation’s leading authorities on campus security and violence in the workplace—such a refusal is disgusting.

In the case of the Appalachian School of Law, Angela Dales received a threatening email several months before she was murdered. The email was in clear violation of both state and federal laws. The school and police failed to thoroughly investigate the email and the sender was never identified. Yet following the shooting, the police asserted the emails had nothing to do with Angela Dales’ murder. If you don’t know who sent the email, how can you make such an assertion? Furthermore, the police refused to let the dead student’s family look at the investigative report. The police did promise to read its content to the family and answer questions. Seven years later the family is still waiting for that to happen.

In 2005, I turned the threatening email over to the FBI. A special agent was aghast saying the email showed all signs of a serial killer and was upset that the Virginia State Police never turned it over to the FBI. The special agent immediately turned the email over to the FBI unit that handled the case that was the basis for The Silence of the Lambs.

In the case of Virginia Tech, the Virginia State Police, the ATF and the gun dealers each refused to provide the Governor’s Review Panel with copies of the applications Cho completed when he bought his weapons or other records relating to any background check that may have done in connection with these purchases. The most horrific school shooting in this country’s history and the state police, the ATF, and the gun dealers refuse to cooperate! This is disgraceful. The Virginia State Police did, however, DESCRIBE the contents of Cho’s gun purchases to members of the panel and its staff.

The failure of the Governor’s Review Panel to have access to all documents in analyzing the shootings and making recommendations, means the Panel’s report is badly flawed. Any one engaged in research on any university campus knows that access to the primary documents is critical to any analysis—hearsay and descriptions make for poor analysis.

Flawed or No Analysis of the Two Shootings

We will never learn if we do not analyze these tragedies, learn from that analysis, and turn the lessons into actions. In the case of the Appalachian School of Law no analysis was ever done. An opportunity was lost, an opportunity that might have helped identify Seung Hui Cho as a threat to himself and others.

In the case of Virginia Tech, the blue-ribbon panel established by Governor Kaine was badly flawed from the outset.

1. The panel was impeded in its work by FOIA rules that did not allow more than two members to meet together or speak by phone without it being considered a public meeting—bureaucracy at its worst.

2. The report did not address issues that needed to be addressed such as identifying mistakes in judgment and the individuals who should be held accountable for their actions or inactions.

3. The panel itself was a prime example of conflict of interest and/or bias. Former Homeland Secretary Tom Ridge publicly stated before the panel convened that the tragedy could not have been prevented—if that is not a bias, I don’t know what is. To suggest that a state panel investigating the activities of a state organization and state employees would be objective is ludicrous. And, there is the state’s appointed representative on the panel—the fact that the families did not select their representative does not speak well for the panel’s objectivity.


4. The final report itself engages in word games; sugar-coating glaring errors. For example the report divides its findings and recommendations into two categories: “What was done well, and what could have been done better.”

SUNY-Oneonta—Excellent Security

If you are looking for an example of an excellent school security program, look at the State University New York. The New York university system is implementing a security program and system that should be the model for all schools. I do not have time to go into it all, and will only say that from a central command post they can lockdown all campus building with four strokes on the computer key board. I have copies of SUNY’s system if anyone is interested.

Many of Virginia’s colleges and universities are woefully behind in implementing campus security plans and measures—woefully behind when compared to schools in other states. That is certainly true when it comes to both the Appalachian School of Law and Virginia Tech University.

I spent nearly one hour discussing campus security with Barton Ingersoll, Chief of University Police, State University of New York—Oneonta (SUNY—Oneonta). He is truly an impressive man in charge of an impressive security operation on a large college campus. If every school in this country had a security plan as well thought out and run as the one at Oneonta, our school grounds would be a far, far safer place. I have copies of the program that is already in place in New York.

The campus security at SUNY-Oneonta is a police department; therefore its officers carry weapons. The Regional Police Academy is tied to the campus police department. The academy runs a wide variety of specialized law enforcement courses, trains new officers, and trains officers to be instructors.

Chief Ingersoll told me that the SUNY-Oneonta campus has had an emergency plan in place since 1994, but since the tragedy at Virginia Tech, the school has tightened and improved campus security. The chief began by telling me that it is against the law to bring a weapon of any kind on a school campus in New York. That law covers both state and private schools. Indeed, every state university in New York is required to have an emergency plan in place, and the Oneonta and Binghamton campuses are the first to meet the state’s standard for security. Highlights of the SUNY—Oneonta plan include:

1. The ability to lock down every building on campus (with the exception of the gym) with four strokes on the computer keyboard.

2. Radio systems in all buildings for emergency use.

3. Blue prints of all campus buildings are on hand in the police headquarters in case of an emergency.

4. A Behavioral Assessment Team that meets every week to discuss student problems and activities. The group is made up of Chief Ingersoll, the Director of Counseling, the Director of Residence Life, the Associate Vice President for Judicial Affairs, the Vice President of Student Development, and the Health Center Director.

5. The Chief of Police has the power to act immediately and to take whatever action he deems necessary if an individual is thought to be a danger to himself or herself or others.

6. A campus-wide siren for notification that there is an emergency on campus.

7. The ability to notify all students, staff, and faculty of an emergency through NY ALERT—a cell phone/email/text messaging system. All New York State University campuses will have this system within the near future.

8. SUNY—Oneonta will soon have in place a video and card access system for all campus buildings.

9. SUNY—Oneonta has bought and installed a sophisticated key system for all buildings. The keys cannot be duplicated.

10. The school gives its officers extensive training through a variety of courses including Active Shooter Course and Patrol Officers Course.

11. SUNY—Oneonta has hired a full-time Emergency Management Coordinator.

12. The school is linked to major criminal data bases in Albany.

13. The school regularly reviews it crime prevention security analysis for all campus buildings.

14. The University Police Department has an ambulance on hand, on campus.


15. It is a state law that university police departments on state affiliated schools must have a Memorandum of Understanding with the state police on immediate emergency response responsibilities and actions. SUNY-Oneonta has such a memorandum and maintains close ties with the New York State Police and the city of Oneonta Police Department.

16. Students are given a full security briefing as part of their campus orientation.

17. Each staff and faculty member has at her or his desk a bright orange Crisis Management folder for immediate and easy reference. The folder contains phone numbers and contacts. The subjects covered are:

a. Emergency Responses—Shelter in Place, Notification, and Building Evacuation.

b. To Report an Emergency on Campus—Bomb Threat, Fire, Accident or Medical Emergency.

c. Threat of Physical Harm from a Person or Persons—Threat by Email, Text Message, Phone, or Note—Threatening or Aggressive Behavior, and Policies and Procedures.

d. Student Emergencies—Disturbed or Disturbing Emotional Behavior, Serious Illness or Injury, Threatening or Irrational Behavior, Crime in Progress or has been Committed, and Sexual Assault.

e. Non-Emergency Student Problems—Disturbed or Disturbing Emotional Behavior, Illness or Injury, and Learning, Psychological, or Physical Disability.

In the final analysis, however, the most sophisticated security system is only as good as the people in charge, the best psychological counseling is only as good as the individuals doing the testing, the best contingency or emergency plans are only as good as the people who implement them.

CONCLUSION: None of us sitting before you has the answer—there is no one answer to these horrific crimes. But it is in forums such as this one at William and Mary that we can begin to find ways to make our campus and school grounds safer. For that reason I want to express my deep and sincere gratitude and thanks to the law school and library of the College of William & Mary, and specifically to you Director Heller for sponsoring this event. And my sincere thanks to the other members of this panel for taking their valuable time to address this serious problem.

We are sitting on the campus of Thomas Jefferson’s college. He drafted one of the greatest documents in history—The Declaration of Independence. That document contains these words, “We hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their creator with certain unalienable Rights that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness…” Thomas Jefferson, a great American, a founding father, a native Virginian, and graduate of the College of William & Mary, put the right to life at the forefront of thoughts and words, the right to life is an unalienable right, a right that came before the Constitution, a right that came before the Bill of Rights.

We must hold people in positions of authority responsible, accountable, and liable for their actions—until we do, our unalienable right to life will not be guaranteed. We must begin to take control of this problem. With those words I thank you and I close.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Denver Post: Poignant Words

Following the recent horrific killings in Alabama and the massacre at the high school in Winnenden, Germany, Denver Post columnist, Mike Littwin, wrote a poignant article capturing the frustrations all of us feel. The blogger added the underlining. His words are worth repeating:

“We are coming up on the 10th anniversary of Columbine, and you can expect new pages filled with tear-stained memories of that horrible day. After 10 years, the old questions will inevitably be asked anew. And we’ll struggle again to discover some kind of meaning from that day.”

“But it turns out the story won’t hold, not after a week of fresh horror. Instead, the old unanswerable questions are being asked in other places. …”

“And it there is one lesson to take from Columbine, it is that whatever happens, we never seem to learn anything. That’s how we come to meet again at the intersection where disturbed young men turn into psychopaths with access to guns.”

“Years later, after too many massacres, the killings are treated more like natural” phenomena—they come, like tsunamis, and then drift from our consciousness, leaving death and sorrow in their wake.”

“In each new town, the story line emerges—the flowers, the poems, the candles, the turn to religion, the questions about a just God, the young people learning far too young the meaning of tragedy, the photographs of the faces twisted in disbelief, the lives of the victims burned into memory.”

Blogger’s note: Littwin too, recognized that the warning signs were ignored in Blacksburg. “And I go to Virginia Tech, where the warning signs we had supposedly learned were ignored so completely that looking for answers seemed beyond hope.”

“At Virginia Tech, we saw a student with serious and documented mental-health issues, who thought that Klebold and Harris were martyrs. Still, he was able to get guns and, as they say, do a Columbine. And those of us who covered Virginia Tech wondered again, if we were contributing to the next one—and what we could possibly do about that.”

“In this story (Virginia Tech) if you remember, the killer had sent a video manifesto to NBC-TV, which had to decide whether to run it. The video gave voice to a killer who barely spoke at all. It was chilling, and it was disturbing and it gave voice, too, to the problems of the modern media.”

“By now, we know too much and too little. Do video games make killers? Not likely. Do would-be killers find a home there? Of course. Do we know enough about guns and disturbed young men and tragedy? Sure. Did we decide in the ongoing culture wars, not to fight about guns anymore? You know the answer.”